The maxim audi alteram partem hear the other side every person is entitled to be heard before an order or judgment is granted against him. The doctrine of audi alteram partem is the basic notion of the principle of natural justice. Audi alteram partem is from a latin phrase audiatur et altera pars. Audi alteram partem in criminal proceedings towards a participatory understanding of criminal justice in europe and latin america. The necessary and sufficient condition for satisfying the audi alteram partem rule is the holding of a procedurally and substantively fair disciplinary hearing. Audi alteram partem legal definition of audi alteram partem. However the applicability of the principles of natural justice depends upon the facts and circumstances of each case. Audi alteram partem definition of audi alteram partem by. The audi alteram partem rule seeks to promote objective and informed decisions.
This ensures a fair hearing and fair justice to both the parties. It then follows with an analysis of the transnational requirements imposed both on the states and the institutions they have set up regionally and globally. The principle of audi alteram partem as practiced by indian courts article shared by there is a good deal of misconception on the question of the right of crossexamination as part of natural justice. This rule covers various stages through which administrative adjudication pasees starting. Hearing audi alteram partem zimbabwe legal information. The second fundamental principle of natural justice is audi alteram partem, i. Audi alteram partem it is a firmly established rule of common law that a judge or anyone exercising a judicial function must hear both sides of every case.
The principle of audi alteram partem as practiced by indian. Audi alteram partem a number of years ago, the then leading scholar of english administrative law concluded. Principle of natural justice in south africa by manjeet. The omnipotency inherent in the doctrine is that no one should be condemned unheard. The key issues in this appeal were due compliance with time set down by the rules of court, and the principle of the audi alteram partem rule right to be heard the court considered whether the court of appeal erred in disregarding the fifth respondents noncompliance of. The primary procedural safeguards in south african administrative law are expressed by the twin principles of natural justice. Audiatur et alteram partem legal definition of audiatur et. Audis good position in the chinese market is the result of a successful partnership stretching back to 1989, initially taking the form of the jointventure project with the chinese first automobile works faw to build the audi 100, and audis inclusion in the fawvolkswagen joint venture for production of the audi 200. Definition no one should be condemned, punished, or deprived of his life or property in any judicial proceeding, unless he had an opportunity of being heard. Get a printable copy pdf file of the complete article 661k, or click on a page image below to browse page by page. It is one of the three basic principles of natural justice, it has come a long way since it first found favour before the english courts since the inception of the common law system. The law is determined by those who make the loudest noise and who talk and write the most and fill the empty spaces in, especially afrikaans, newspapers and they are, without exception, those who for some or other. The audi alteram partem rule, which is the foundation of natural justice, has never been applied to members of the security branch. In the field of administrative decisions, this principle has been applied to unsure fair play and justice to affected persons.
Section 24 of the interim constitution, section 33 of the final constitution and the promotion of administrative justice act 3 of 2000 were introduced to safeguard the individual against unfair administrative action. Oct 05, 2018 in common law, the principle audi alteram partem listen to the other side seeks to ensure that, however strong ones own arguments and however compelling ones own case, the opposing side is given a fair hearing and accorded a right of reply. In common law, the principle audi alteram partem listen to the other side seeks to ensure that, however strong ones own arguments and however compelling ones own case, the opposing side is given a fair hearing and accorded a right of reply. The main aim of this rule is that the principles of fairness and impartiality must be observed by treating all the parties to dispute fairly and equally. Audi alteram partem or rule of fair hearing the principle of audi alteram partem is the basic concept of principle of natural justice. The second rule is audi alteram partem, that is, hear the other side. This is a very strong rule which means no one will be judged without fair hearing. Full text full text is available as a scanned copy of the original print version.
This chapter looks at the traditional legal maxim, audi alteram partem, from the same angle used earlier with regard to the requirement to carry out a procedure. A corollary has been deduced from the above two rules and particularly the audi alteram partem rule, namely qui aliquid. Focusing on both national criminal proceedings and transnational cases, this study employs a comparative law approach to examine the shift. The key issues in this appeal were due compliance with time set down by the rules of court, and the principle of the audi alteram partem rule right to be heard the court considered whether the court of appeal erred in disregarding the fifth respondents noncompliance of time set down for filing statement of defence. The doctrine says that no one should be condemned unheard. Dicey more than a century ago, the purpose of the rule of law was to protect basic individual rights by requiring the government. For the benefit of future discussion, the chapter highlights three main. Audi alteram partem in criminal proceedings towards a. Thus it is important that it be observed prior to the deision. Secondly, it argued that the arbitrator was biased, as well as. The principle of audi alteram partem as practiced by. This principle is sine qua non of every civilized society.
Meaning latin phrase meaning hear the other side no man shall be condemned unheard. This requirement is meticulously enforced in that an opponent must. The right to a fair hearing audi alteram partem hear the other side. Everything that affects a citizen in his civil life inflicts a civil consequence. Audi alteram partem or audiatur et altera pars is a latin phrase meaning listen to the other side, or let the other side be heard as well. The principle allows for the person against whom an action is taken or whose rights are infringed to defend himself and be heard accordingly.
It is the principle underpinning the intellectual exchange on this site, an exchange between evangelical and reformed theology and modern and. Audi alteram partem administrative law notes ballb notes. It is the principle that no person should be judged without a fair hearing in which each party is given the opportunity to respond to the evidence against them. Jul 07, 2010 audi alteram partem, the latin expression well ingrained in the common law legal system translated in english means no one should be condemned unheard. Partem in english, translation, latinenglish dictionary.
This doctrine states the no one shall be condemned unheard. Maxims audi alteram partem applicability of to decision to discharge public service employee in terms of s 15a1 of kwazulu public service act 18 of 1985. Audi alteram partem second long arm of natural justice protecting the little man from arbitrary administrative actions. Nov 02, 2017 audi alteram partem rule as applied in employment disputes is regulated by legislation and only requires a right to be heard and not a formal hearing.
It embodies the concept in criminal law that no person should be condemned unheard. This is based on the principles of natural justice and ensures a just and fair hearing. Natural justice nemo debet esse judex in propria causa. Wong ah suan, 7 the court emphasizes that if a person were to be deprived of any of their rights, the. Audi alteram partem rule as applied in employment disputes is regulated by legislation and only requires a right to be heard and not a formal hearing.
Wherever an administration action inflicts a civil consequence, principles of natural justice have to be followed. The court of justice found that the failure to hear a thirdcountry national in the course of proceedings relating to an extension of the. The applicant argued that the award was in conflict with public policy in that there was a breach of the audi alteram partem rule because, although it was given an opportunity to be heard, its submissions were rejected by the arbitrator in favour of those of the first respondent. The principle of audi alteram partem is one of the basic concepts of the principle of natural justice. In an editorial in the last issue of the journal which i have read with a great deal of interest, you attempt to draw a comparison between the results of the medical and the surgical treatment of acute intestinal obstruction, and you claim that whereas 30 per cent, recover after medical treatment, 68. About minimal audi alteram partem audi alteram partem. For the benefit of future discussion, the chapter highlights three main points. It is often possible to comply with the audi alteram partem rule without incurring any risk of being mistaken for a participant in the proceedings before a court of justice. The expression audi alteram partem implies that a person must be given opportunity to defend himself. Audi alteram partem means hear the other side, or no man should be condemned unheared or both the sides must be heard before passing any order. The principle of audi alteram partem is the basic concept of the principle of natural justice. This rule is recognized in england as one of fundamental1 justice, and a failure to observe it makes the whole proceeding defective and voidable.
General overview the idea of constitutionalism is bolstered by the specific entrenchment of the rule of law. As originally conceived by the english constitutional lawyer, a. All that you need to know about audi alteram partem. This doctrine gives a right that one shall be condemned of anything without being heard. Here by fairness is meant that all the parties to dispute be given. Jpg image create medium jpg image create large jpg image create largest jpg image create smallest pdf file create small pdf file create medium pdf file create large pdf file create largest pdf file. Principle of natural justice in south africa by manjeet sahu. The notion that an individual, whose life, liberty, or property are in legal jeopardy, has the right to confront the evidence against him or her in a fair hearing is one of the fundamental principles of constitutional law in the united. At times and particularly in continental countries, the form audietur at altera pars is used, meaning very much the same thing. Tracing the need for the application of the doctrine audi. Its meaning is also the same as hear the other side. This book analyses current developments in europe and latin america towards the greater involvement of the parties in the administration of criminal justice. Audi alteram partem in criminal proceedings springerlink. Audi alteram partem which is the latin word for the rule of fair hearing means that unless a person is heard he must not be condemned.
977 636 128 489 66 247 49 627 1075 79 501 1414 1321 490 62 258 1181 1353 812 793 1307 502 1311 176 694 874 720 1161 115 1002 67 327 114 1105 842 1498 548 468 742 1039